Honours
| 1890 | Poole Rovers and Poole Hornets merge |
| 1891 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1893 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1895 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| 1896 | Enter Dorset League |
| Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up | |
| 1897 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| 1900 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1901 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1902 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| 1903 | Joined Hampshire League West Division |
| 1904 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| 1905 | Hampshire League until 1909/10 |
| 1907 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners (keep original trophy after 5th win) |
| 1910/11 | Back in Dorset League |
| 1911 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 3rd spell in Hampshire League West Division | |
| 1921/22 | Enter Hampshire County Division |
| 1923 | Enter Western League for 3 years |
| 1926 | Enter Southern League (turn professional) |
| FA
Cup: Beat Newport County 1-0 at home. In 3rd round proper, Poole Town lost 3-1 to Everton at Goodison Park in front of 65,000 (Dixie Dean scored hat-trick for Everton) |
|
| Dorset Senior Cup Winners | |
| 1927 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| 1928 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1930-34 | Enter Western League |
| 1933 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1934/35 | Enter Hampshire League Division 1 |
| 1935-57 | Back in Western League |
| 1937 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1938 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| 1947 | FA Cup 1st Round proper: Drew 2-2 at Loftus Road, QPR - lost replay 6-0 |
| Dorset Senior Cup Winners | |
| 1946/7 | Western League Runners Up |
| 1949 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1949/50 | Western League Runners Up |
| 1951 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1952 | Turned professional for a second time |
| 1953/54 | Western League Runners Up |
| 1955 | Western League Cup Runners Up |
| 1955/56 | Western League Runners Up |
| 1956/57 | Western League Champions |
| 1957 | Join Southern League |
| 1959 | Founder Members of Southern Premier League |
| 1961/62 | Southern Division Runners Up |
| 1962 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1963 | FA Cup 1st Round proper: Drew 2-2 with Watford at Vicarage Road - lost replay |
| 1966 | FA Cup 1st Round proper: Lost 2-1 to QPR at Loftus Road |
| 1975 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| 1981 | Anglo Italian Cup Runners Up (in Italy) |
| 1984 | FA Cup 1st Round proper: Drew 0-0 with Newport County at home - lost replay 3-1 |
| 1988 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1988/89 | Southern Division Runners Up |
| 1989 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| 1991/92 | Relegated from Southern Premier League |
| 1993 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1994 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| Poole Town move out of Poole Stadium - ground share with Hamworthy United | |
| 1995 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 1995/96 | Relegated from Southern League - Enter Hampshire League |
| 1998 | Dorset Senior Cup Winners |
| Trophyman Cup Winners | |
| 1999 | Hampshire Division 1 Runners Up |
| Trophyman Cup Winners (first team to retain trophy) | |
| 2000 | Hampshire Division 1 Champions |
| 2001 | Hampshire Premier League Runners Up |
| 2004 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |
| 2005 | Wessex Division 2 Runners Up |
| 2006 | Dorset Senior Cup Runners Up |